As the Seahawks and Rams gird for the winner-take-all season finale Sunday, we still don’t know whether Hasselbeck or Whitehurst will take the snaps at kickoff. (Nor do we have a very good sense on whether Seattle fans in attendance will be rooting for their team to win.)  But one thing we do know: even in his golden years, there’s still a pretty huge gulf between what Hasselbeck can do and what Whitehurst has shown so far.

I went back and watched all of Whitehurst’s throws from his last two games and came away with a Kyle Boller kind of feeling. This is a guy who just doesn’t seem to have command or touch, and who shouldn’t be asked to carry a team on his shoulders. However it's hard to tell, because for the most part, Seahawks coach Pete Carroll and offensive coordinator Jeremy Bates have not been willing to let him. 

To get my own take, I went back and watched every snap he took over the last two weeks. n five quarters of work, he completed 19 of 34 passes for 149 yards, with 0 TDs and 0 INTs. Here’s a scouting report on each of these pass attempts, after the break:

To the 2010 year that has seen our Rams crawl, and then walk, and then run at last, I will run to my bar, walk with my friends, then crawl home at last. To each pick of our draft, I drink each a draught. And for each proudly held win, I toast again and again.

To Week 3, and the Washington Redskins

'Tis a strange chemistry that brews in a team,
sometimes it works and fits like a dream.

But two old heads poured into the same dram,
just couldn't mix like a good black and tan.

Sometimes 'tis better to start over anew,
and just let the kids do what kids do:

Make the most out of a good second chance,
and prove not to be the same sorry old Rams.

To Week 4, and the Seattle Seahawks

If your enemy's enemy your friend should be,
We've welcomed any who beats up on thee.

But watching while others go have all the fun
Just didn't satisfy when we couldna beat none.

So it's a special good cheer to end this bad streak,
E'en if we can't recollect much of that week

One win back then is nothing to boast
but to do it again would be reason to toast!

To Week 6, and the San Diego Chargers

From opposite directions we did come
a contender and pretender did meet in the Dome

But perhaps some role reversal's in order
Did our team win when your team oughta?

Or did your team think cheap shots were enough
to take out a kid who's not s'posed to be tough?

A hard lesson came while we learned how to win
But don't drown in your misery, join me in gin!

The Rams future nemesis?

MaioccoCSN
Just spoke with first-known person interviewed for 49ers GM job, Tony Softli: "Everything went well and I'm excited about the opportunity."

The Rams might never admit it, but there has to be a certain amount of pride and schadenfreude in not only beating the 49ers, but in knocking their organization askew with the firing of Mike Singletary. Now a team with no head goes looking for one, and decides to look hard at former Rams VP of player personnel, Tony Softli.

cliffhanger989
@SoftliSTL heard u interviewed with the 49ers. If their smart they will hire u

From a competitive intelligence standpoint, this move makes perfect sense. Softli, one of the few executives from the dysfunctional hydra-headed Zygmunt era to survive the transition to the streamlined Billy Devaney/Steve Spagnuolo one, is intimately familiar with the Rams' inner workings and personnel philosophy. He is also a valued football mind who recruited some of the players, like Cliff Ryan, who formed the essential core of young depth that the Rams have been rebuilding around.

The 49ers are widely considered to be the most talented team in the division, particularly on defense, but a team with two clear needs -- sane, steady leadership and a trustworthy talent at quarterback. Softli knows a little something about both, having participated in the decision to hire Coach Spagnuolo, and submitting this scouting report on Sam Bradford prior to the draft. 

While Softli has an incumbent to dethrone in current player-personnel man Trent Baalke, and may have more competitors from actively employed candidates from other NFL teams once their seasons conclude, Softli's inherent ties to a rising power in the NFC West might make him the ideal candidate for the job.

And yes, by "rising power in the NFC West," I meant the Rams. What a difference a year makes, no?

Do the Rams have a legitimate deep threat in Danario Alexander? Consider this question answered.

Midway through the second quarter, up 9-7 but trying to shake the cobwebs on offense after consecutive three-and-outs, Pat Shurmur went back to his passing game to move the chains, and with a 3rd and 4 on the doorstep of the red zone, he dialed up that most elusive weapon in the Rams' arsenal -- the deep ball.

However, Danny Amendola never got clean separation from Nate Clements in the slot, and slowed to half speed at the five as the ball sailed unmolested into the end zone. It was an ugly play that left Rams fans discontented, even as Josh Brown kicked away to briefly extend the lead to 12-7.

ottoman89
Bradford throws a beautiful deep pass, but his receivers constantly lose the ball in the air.

RossMiles
@RamsHerd @ottoman89 I have been trying to tell @Daniel_Doelling & @TurfShowTimes this is why we don't go deep! Our WR can't cope!

A disheartening sequence sent the Rams into the tunnel down 14-12, and set Rams fans all a-twitter. This long-simmering debate came to a head: should Pat Shurmur even bother dialing up deep passes with these receivers? Leading the dissent was old-school Rams tweeter @RossMiles, with @ottoman89, @Daniel_Doelling, @TurfShowTimes and good old @RamsHerd chirping in debate. But one Rams player was yet to have his say: Danario Alexander, who chipped in a game-changing performance. 

After the break, RamsHerd provides a play-by-play breakdown of the true impact of Danario's season-high 40 snaps. 

Week 16: 49ers (5-9) at Rams (6-8)

Dec 26, 2010. 12:00

17 25

NFL.com: Recap | Box Score | Video

The Rams moved one step closer to their first NFC West crown since 2003 with a white-knuckled win over the discombobulated and deeply flawed San Francisco 49ers. No doubt the national media will mercilessly flog the Niners while contradictorily holding them up as the poster child for the flawed NFC West, but they would be missing the big story of this game. Today, the Rams played what they called a "playoff game," and in the second half, actually raised their game to playoff-caliber football.

While the execution wasn't always pretty, the Rams followed Amendola's blueprint to the most important home win in a long time. 

It wasn't quite a do-or-die game for Steve Spagnuolo's team, but it was for Mike Singletary's squad, and we wondered how each team would respond. Spagnuolo focused on "intensity," and quietly built a gameplan on offense to put the game in Sam Bradford's hands. Singletary waffled on his quarterback, choosing his boom-or-bust big-play threat, setting the tone for this game. It was going to be all or nothing for the Niners.

In the end, it was nothing, and as the Rams head to a true win-or-go-home game in Seattle, Mike Singletary will be hitting the ranks of the unemployed.

CL7TWO
big win today thank you to all the fans who came out and supported us today and throughout the year. see u guys in 2 weeks, lets go get a W!

The Rams delighted their near-sellout crowd by mixing some daring risks into their normally kid-safe playbook right from the opening drive. After six plays (four passes, two runs) Shurmur dialed up a textbook end-around to Danny Amendola that morphed into something unexpected: Amendola's first ever NFL pass attempt. It was a rainbow to a double-covered Danario Alexander deep downfield that should have been intercepted, but veteran CB Nate Clements plowed through the Rams receiver for an egregious pass interference call and a first-and-goal Rams. A big gamble to go for the throat early led to a Niners' mistake, and a huge momentum-setting play. And a snowplow run by Steven Jackson and the Rams had a 7-0 lead in front of the giddy home faithful.

A comical series of events from the 49ers -- highlighted by two botched snaps, one leading to a safety -- and another huge pass completion to Brandon Gibson set the Rams up deep in the red zone. In the closing seconds of the first quarter, it looked as though the Rams could run away with this game. Of course, as still-healing Rams fans know, it's never that easy.

Fumble. Three and out. Three and out. Punt to Ted Ginn Jr and stand about as he races untouched to the end zone, and suddenly a 49ers team whose only accomplishment thus far was racking up penalties is within two points. Rams answer 7 with 3, and Troy Smith completes two huge plays -- 25 yards to Vernon Davis, 60 yards to Michael Crabtree -- and the visitors suddenly looked poised to complete every St Louisan's nightmare scenario.

The Rams went in the tunnel down 14-12, leaving a stunned crowd to contemplate, for 20 minutes, what the hell they had gotten so fired up for. How had the 49ers sucked all the momentum out of the building? Was this to be the same old Rams, after all?

Sometimes, though, football is a deceptively simple game to analyze. When the bell rang for the second half, one team got out of the corner and was simply better than the other, and that team was the Rams. They kicked off to San Francisco and the Rams defense set about shattering the eggshell-thin veneer of confidence that the 49ers held about themselves.

Six plays later, that job was done:

As it turns out, all it took was a good pass rush and an easy interception by Singletary's future son-in-law, Oshiomogo Atogwe, leading to this epic meltdown on the sideline. It also led to a Rams field goal, and a 15-14 lead that our boys in blue steadily reinvested in like a good nest egg. After three drives of three-and-out in the first half, the Rams had none in the second, trucking consistently and methodically down the field by giving Bradford the keys and letting him drive.

And here's the key stat, especially for an offensive line that has been earning withering scorn for their inability to open running lanes: on 38 dropbacks by their budding star quarterback, Sam Bradford was only hit twice, only sacked once.

Bradford got all of his key receivers involved in the second half, hitting Brandon Gibson, Laurent Robinson, Danny Amendola and Daniel Fells for key gains, while racking up 168 yards passing in the latter frame. The biggest play of them all, a 46 yard strike down the left sideline, went to Danario Alexander, who is suddenly healthy and looking like a serious X factor in the weeks to come.

Yes, I said "weeks", with an S. Because the Rams now firmly control their destiny, and head up to Seattle to complete Mission Improbable: winning the NFC West and bringing a playoff game back to these bewildered and delighted Saint Louis Rams fans.

We won't know what hit us.

Rams-Niners II: Trying to reverse the curse. 

With Rams-Niners week reaching a fever pitch, this makes a perfect opportunity to reach out to Josh at The Red and Gold to exchange some questions and answers. (You may remember Josh's work from Niners Nuggets on the Fanball network -- like us, he has migrated over to Bloguin and is keeping the fire burning.)

RamsHerd: Are you surprised that Singletary went with Troy Smith in this game, and do you think it's the right move?

The Red and Gold: I wish I was more surprised by Singletary's move back to Troy Smith. Fact is, Alex Smith had his last legitimate chance against the Chargers and laid a big egg. Troy Smith is more mobile, more apt to make the big plays and has a good grasp of the system. I also think it's a plus that he performed very well against the Rams in San Francisco back in week 10 with 356 yards passing and a touchdown with no interceptions.

Mike Singletary and offensive coordinator Mike Johnson seem to have the 'which Smith' debate every week. I've never been an Alex Smith fan and I think going with Troy Smith for this game is the right decision.

RH: The Niners' offense was wide open in your first matchup with the Rams. Should we expect more of the same, or was that an aberration?

TR&G: It's a little tough to predict because the 49ers offense has been so erratic and inconsistent all year but with Troy Smith at the helm and with the 49ers season on the line, I would anticipate it being a wide open game. I think Troy will be throwing a lot downfield and hopefully keeping the Rams off-balance with his threat to run. Alex Smith at QB is a little more conservative but I'll be we see Troy taking his fair share of shots downfield and continuing to get Brian Westbrook involved in the offense.

RH: Your draft this year produced two key components toward rebuilding the offensive line. How have they performed, and did they fill the team's biggest need?

TR&G: Both Anthony Davis and Mike Iupati filled big needs for the 49ers and both have performed well. Davis has had more struggles this season but it seems like he'll be a good long-term solution. As for Iupati, I've read that some already consider him one of the top 5 guards in the NFL, regardless of experience. That might be a bit of a stretch, but he has definitely played well and is much more consistent. As you know, the less you hear about an offensive lineman, the better he is. That has been the case much more with Iupati than Davis.

As for biggest need, it is clear this season that the 49ers have more needs than they thought. Their three biggest needs this offseason (in my opinion) will be quarterback, head coach and offensive coordinator. The defense has also been a disappointment and addressing a cornerback and probably outside linebacker will be critical as well.

RH: Obviously, this isn't the year most people thought the 49ers would have. Does the possibility of winning the division absolve all wounds, or are there troubles that run so deep that this team is in need of change regardless?

TR&G: If the 49ers somehow win this weak division, I don't think all will be absolved - unless they go deeper into the playoffs. There are too many big issues on this team. Mike Singletary is not the team's long-term solution at head coach and I don't think should be coaching any team for a while. He would make a good coordinator but he just isn't ready. The 49ers are working on building a new stadium in Santa Clara and need all of the good will and fan support they can get. They are not going to get it by underwhelming next season again. The 49ers fired their offensive coordinator, Jimmy Raye, a few games into the season and replaced him with Mike Johnson. He's not ready either to call the offense for an NFL team. It starts at the top and goes from there. I think the 49ers next year will be a drastically different team on the field and in the front office.

RH: Game prediction?

TR&G: I am going to be optimistic and say 23-19 (I am also optimistic on my fantasy team as well since I have Josh Brown as my kicker). I think the 49ers squeak this one out like the last one...

Troy Smith: fear him?

Mike Singletary's last shred of patience with Alex Smith lasted a damn short while -- two starts, one good, one bad, which is about what you get. This week against the Rams, he has decided to see if lightning can strike twice: he's named Troy Smith as the starting quarterback. That shiver  you just felt run down your back? That's cold illogical fear -- not a pure animal fear that you might have against a monster opponent like a Drew Brees or Tom Brady, but a fear borne of shame. A fear that asks into the dark: "Can we really let Troy Smith have his way with us ... twice?"

Fellow Bloguin man Josh over at The Red and The Gold offered this take on Singletary's now constant vacillation at the helm of this team:

Now that he's apparently made up his mind, though, it falls to the Rams to prevent Troy Smith from showing the same magic he did in their first matchup. The numbers are simply astounding...

* one of his TDs in Week 10 was a rushing score.
** Smith has only started two games in his career before this season, both in his rookie season.

The simple fact is, the Rams' softness on big plays made Troy Smith look like a brand new quarterback. And while I generally frown on the Steve Spurrier philosophy of interchangeable QBs, in this case, why not gamble and dare the Rams to stop you? 

For the Rams, this game offers a big chance at redemption, especially in the secondary. The timid play of the Rams' CBs -- notably against the Saints, as VanRam at TurfShowTimes pointed out:

Also notable in that New Orleans game was the consistent depth that the Rams' DBs gave up in front to the fleet core of Saints receivers. Even on a third-and-three, our corners were consistently lined up 6-8 yards off the line of scrimmage, all but conceding the first down rather than get burned big plays...

Exactly the kind of big plays that Troy Smith and the Niners blitzed us with just a few weeks earlier. The Rams' defensive mojo has not been right since that week. This rematch on the home turf offers as good a chance to get it back as we will have, as we push forward toward the next level.